Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Thinky stuff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thinky stuff. Show all posts

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Thinky stuff: If She Dies, You Die


I just came across this blog post this morning and I thought you should read it too. It's really quite good. The writer Jason Killingsworth, features editor for Edge, laments about the temporary separation from his wife. This leads to a discussion of how games like Enslaved and Ico are very good at emphasizing overtly or subtly the idea of bonding with that special someone in your life, about what it means to be married, and what it means to lose the person you love.

Read it. Good advice on marriage too.

Friday, September 24, 2010

Thinky stuff: Mafia 2 - wasted opportunity


Mafia 2 could've been a far better game if 2K Czech ditched the American gangster story for something completely fresh and different. I've thought about this a little deeper because it would be unfair to discount the devs who clearly put effort into this otherwise abysmal sequel.

Hear me out.

---

I've talked a fair bit already about my disappointment for Mafia 2's story. It's cliched and the protagonist remains largely unidentifiable. I'm also sick of the American gangster's story because that's all we ever get i.e. The Departed, American Gangster, Godfather, Mario Puzo's works, etc.

Then I also read a recent article about the new World War 2 RTS Ruse. The writer of this article considered it a wasted opportunity for the French devs of Ruse, Eugen Systems to make a war game from the American perspective because once again, that's already beaten to death. They could've instead dug deep into their own national history and done a story about the French resistance. Granted, it wouldn't have been as popular or accessible as the American story, but heck, it'd be something different.

They had an opportunity to expand our knowledge of a war that, in my mind, has been overused in video games to the point that it has lost its awesome mythical quality (and why everybody is now jumping on the modern warfare bandwagon). But I don't want to get into that debate right now. Anyway, if you're interested to read the article in its entirety, click here.


But my point is, in bringing up this Ruse story, 2K Czech should've also delved into their own history to tell a Czechian gangster story. And why not? Granted, the Czechian story may not be as peachy, shiny or as "Fergetaboutit" as the American Italian's, but brutality and grittiness worked well for Australian crime TV Underbelly and Russian mob film Eastern Promises. And the fact that very few gamers, other than perhaps Czechian ones or historians, know much about a mobster's life in the Czech Republic, I think that's good enough justification to tell a new story.

There's this funny story I was reading in the UK Daily Mail about Czechian mobs setting up sham weddings in order to beat immigration in Eastern Europe. We could have a mission in Czechian Mafia 2 where that was exactly what was happening - a sham wedding. It would be hilarious if the script was written right and then suddenly the cops bust down the church doors to break it up, and then it's shootfest that'll go down well with trigger-happy gamers.

The games industry is problematic in that it is, for now, still driven by sales, at which point, you either go indie or pander to the desires of everybody. Why doesn't anybody write a video game about being a citizen in North Korea trying to escape across the border? You can still have violence and gun play but at least that's a new story no one's ever told.

It's always the same archetypal heroes; people want their Anglo-centric Nathan Drakes and Prince of Persias with their sarcastic-slightly-cocky-attitudes-but-deep-down-are-nice-guys or the Vitos and the Scarlettis with their "Fergetaboutit" accents. And not the dirt farmer from outside Prague with 5 kids and a sick wife, who gets tangled with the wrong people in his attempt to earn a living for his family. Now THAT'S a mob story I'd like to play.



Monday, September 13, 2010

Thinky stuff: Narrative is top dog


I was being a bit cynical and daft when I wrote two posts ago about how video game storytelling sucks! I still stand by my belief that conventional forms of plot and narratives are horrifically juxtaposed with the play element of those new titles mentioned.

But I cannot consider myself a gaming enthusiast if I didn't think about this a little harder. There are a lot of arguments to counter what I said in that post, a whole lot of them much more respectful of the notion of video games, and what they have to offer as a form of expression, separate from other mediums.

I guess I've lost my way a little in understanding games deeper than the flashbang of shiny graphics and exciting gun play. So I had a chat with a good friend, Dr. Thomas Apperley who is a lecturer at the University of New England in Australia. I've transcribed our discussion below as if it were a faux Socratic dialogue.

Read on if you want some truth bombs on gaming as a form of narrative.

---

Me: I stand by my point that the latest video games out there have really bad storytelling. I know you're all like "meh, storytelling is not the point of games" but man, I'm so sick of playing something that doesn't compel me on.

Tom: If you are playing video games for the story you have missed the point. That doesn't mean games should be allowed bad stories though.

Me: I think it depends on how some video games are sold to audiences. Take Mafia 2 for instance. You can't go into that title without expecting a damn good "Godfather"-like plot. Of course, how it plays is important too but that is an example of a game that is married heavily to its story. It's no Mario, where you can just go, "Okay, I don't really care that Bowser's kidnapped the princess. I've got to go eat me some stars."

Tom: Yep.

Me: So I guess my point is, games that want to act like they've got a really important story to tell should tell a damn important story. Like Assassin's Creed 2, that game may have played well (although certain parts were unnecessarily pointless), but the story could've been a whole lot better.

Tom: It doesn't have to be a conflict, story vs gameplay. Think instead of gameplay as a mode of telling stories that has yet to be realized (fully).

Me: OMG I'm such a dumbass. You're right, I've been so caught up in storytelling as a completely separate element. This is like Gaming 101.

Tom: Right, people always tell stories. And storytelling adapt to the medium. But we've been very busy imposing current ideas about stories onto games which doesn't acknowledge the moves [games] have made towards being their own medium of communication.

Me: I feel stupid LOL. That's the fundamental point isn't it? It's because games exist as a separate medium, from the conventions we already know for storytelling through film, TV, books.

Tom: Yeah, games can use normative forms of storytelling but sometimes it doesn't work. It doesn't drive the game forward; think of gaming as de-hierarchizing narratives and foregrounding action.

Me: This is new. "De-hierarchizing". So what you're saying is narratives as not conventionally told.

Tom: Narrative is top dog. But in games, narrative is tied up with a bunch of other stuff. Or even deliberately suggested, e.g. multiplayer shooters. No narrative needed. Just weapons and environments.

Me: Or you could say the narrative is the whole "war story" in which you are placed.

Tom: Yep, the narrative is the world.

Me: Okay, then here's an interesting thing to consider. Kane & Lynch 2, a story about a bunch of gangster dudes causing a riot in Shanghai. I guess I'd LIKE there to be a plot other than just two guys who keep getting caught up in shit and having to shoot everybody that moves. But that's a kind of storytelling too right? It goes in line with the action which is all about running from one level to the next, and shooting things. But it fails only because the action is unvaried, therefore the plot is unvaried.

Tom: Right, but that sounds like a design flaw too.

Me: Yeah, exactly. Which is why Kane & Lynch 2 reviewed poorly amongst critics.

Tom: Because it's a poorly designed game.

Me: That, and also because the story really does suck. Okay, if I were to throw this ball out of left-field, what would you say is the best storytelling in a game you've seen in the last couple of years?

Tom: Half-Life 2, KotOR, Mass Effect, Bioshock...

Me: I would be most inclined to say that out of all those titles you've mentioned, Bioshock does it best. The first three compel a player to keep playing because of the immersive world, characters, and everything. Bioshock at first glance, does the same with Rapture. But there is that meta-narrative about "players playing video games and being blind sheep" that blows my mind. Which is why it's kind of a shame that Bioshock 2 didn't have anything new or profound to say. But then again, we can't expect it to pull as epic a concept as the first game.

Tom: How could it? The joke was revealed.

Me: Yeah exactly. But my point is, are there other jokes still to be told?

Tom: Sure, man.

Me: Just our brains are not as capable as Ken Levine's LOL.

In conclusion, I think a lot of gamers take for granted, as I have done, the capability for video games to combine interactivity with storytelling. Which is why Starcraft 2 is not about some dude who is trying to save the galaxy. The narrative is about your Protoss play, the strategies you employ, or my Zerg rush or how I won despite being outnumbered and outgunned. Just as Left 4 Dead is about everyone's personal horror story with zombies, with teammates, or how you survived a crazy onslaught at some shopping mall just a hair's breath away from death.

In other news, if you like what Tom spoke about up there, he's written a whole book on video games which is available for download here.

TOD #6: Gaming Rhythms: Play and Counterplay from the Situated to the Global by Dr. Thomas Apperley. I command you to read it, you'll learn something.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Thinky Stuff: Video games storytelling sucks!


I'm having a crisis of faith in video games.

Yes, I have not blogged for a month, but let me explain.

1. I just graduated from university.
2. I've been caught up with looking for jobs
3. I've been writing
4. Making a short film
5. The games that have come out of late has sucked real bad

Wait, what was that last one again?

That's right, you heard me, the games that have come out of late SUCKS.

---

Kane & Lynch 2 disappointed me so much. I confess I must've gone nuts when I set hands on the demo. In demo form, the hyper-tension of action setpieces were thrilling, and the gaming world hadn't seen anything so brutal in a long time. But the game in its entirety is a farce; born of stupidity, tactlessness and little care for a well-written story. It's just one endless violent ride with no respite. And it is so grim I don't feel like I'm having fun playing at all. Kane and Lynch just keep getting into "Oh f*ck" moments, people just keep wanting to kill them. The shooting works fine for awhile and then it just goes on without stopping or having any variation.


Starcraft 2
is for the drones. Sure, the fanatics will say it is a return to form for Blizzard and all that hyper clicking will not only improve finger dexterity for other uses in real life, but truly we just like old Starcraft but need new graphics for it. I'm fine with all that hullabaloo but when Blizzard pours gazillions of dollars into this epic video game that will make them even more money (because of South Korea alone), they could have at least written a story to blow the mind. Instead, we have a dull story about a dull captain trying to save a dull universe. And man, is the dialogue horrific.


Mafia 2.
I wanted very much to like this game. The first was stellar, a contrast to GTA back when GTA was still lame-brained. But now Rockstar has produced a classic in Red Dead Redemption and Mafia 2 in comparison is a regression. The protagonist is horribly unidentifiable: he only wants shortcuts in life, has no qualms about doing bad deeds and looks too stupid to be really heroic, and it's a cliched story if I saw any. A man trying to make it but comes to terms with the dark underbelly that is the American gangster way. And ohmygawd, have developers not learnt that no one wants to spend half the game chauffeuring themselves or other people around, especially not in old automobile rustbuckets. And as shiny as the cutscenes are, they are really quite empty of any real revelations or profound stories.


I think the underlying problem with all these latest releases is that none of them have a story that really matters. I know that games should first and foremost be about the gaming as opposed to the storytelling, but as a writer myself, I believe that the most compelling games (outside of Mario and Tetris) are the ones that can move you with a plot and characters.

If we want video games to get out of loserdom (I just watched Glee) and join the popular kids TV, film, and music, they've got to keep up their interactive qualities but also strive for excellence in storytelling. A bad story ruins the illusion, a bad story doesn't keep us playing. That's all.

Peace out.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Thinky stuff: Review scores


This blog is just a little over a year old. A feat in itself as I've always dropped off interest after a short while, with many of my older blogs. But I love this blog because I get to objectively and honestly talk about the thing I love most, video games.

I've done a number of reviews over the year and hope to keep writing some more, but I've always had trouble giving an objective score. Sometimes my write-up might portray a game in an average to poor light but the score reflects something higher than that. Or so I have been informed by friends a few times.

This is normally what I do with scoring: I compare how the game fares in individual categories (i.e. graphics, gameplay, sound) to other video games like it. But I came to realize that the final score may not even be the best reflection of my opinion on the game. Also, I know there will be those who skip to the end of my review just to see what score I gave it. I'd rather people take the time to read the words I've slaved over which not only shows appreciation for my work, but will do the game justice.

I was reading several interesting articles about review scoring (here, here, and here) and how even the most reputable gaming websites don't use the full 1 - 10 scoring range, instead employing a more skewed-towards-niceness 6 - 10 range. Some see 7/10 as a really decent score, a game still worth playing, although in my mind, that number represents a game that your time should not be wasted on unless there really is nothing else to play. And 6, well that's shite. But it's still confusing though; I never use 1 - 5 because subconsciously, I'm thinking as long as a game is playable, it should get above a 6. Rock Paper Shotgun on the other hand doesn't give scores on their reviews because 1. it's confusing and 2. they believe they aren't the be-all, end-all authority worthy of giving final scores.

Hence, I believe I shall take the same approach from here-on out. If you visit my blog now, you will notice that all my reviews have had their scores removed. I want to encourage people to read my words, and I want to be honest that I am not well-positioned or experienced enough to be giving scores. Furthermore, it takes a huge weight off my shoulders because scoring a game, truly is like making the final word on it. And that's a heck load of responsibility.

You have no idea how many nights I'd worry about the latest games I'd scored, whether or not it was spot on with the game's worth. But all that's over now with this change. I'm glad because it also means my blog is growing in maturity.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Thinky stuff: The importance of the games journalist


The other day, I had an interesting discussion with a mate who told me it's not right that I go apeshit on game developers in my reviews, if they don't live up to my ridiculously high standards. That I and other reviewers are being obnoxious in what we do. My friend has a good point. After all, game devs put a lot of effort into their craft. Why should we criticize if we only consume and not contribute?

In my opinion however, someone's got to have those high standards if we're to get any advancement in games development.

I'm not trying to prove my friend wrong with this post, but I am going to think more about what it means to write a review.

---

Journalists are not artists. They aren't the ones that mold sculptures, direct films, produce TV shows, or make music. Yet they are a step up from the simple consumption that the masses engage in. Journalists take that extra step to reflect on what it is they've consumed. Granted, the masses are capable of reflection too, and I'm very certain a lot do but where journalists are better and significant to the process is that they've taken their extensive experiences on their chosen subject matters/passions, in order to critically posit the artistic work of another in the time-line of our human existence.

By critically positing an artistic work, we are able to see how far we've come from the simple drawings found in caves all those centuries ago. The same is true for games development. It may still be a young art form but it's fueled by rapid technological advancement so in the gazillion years it takes for us to develop other art forms, it only takes fourteen to go from The Day of the Tentacle to Crysis. In that sense, if there are no journalists, no critics to say what needs to be said, the evolution of game development comes to a halt. The weeds will not be rooted out, and the bad stuff will just keep getting worse. Of course the developers are the primary catalysts for the evolution of video games, but the journalists are just as vital. The latter are especially needed in an industry where development is volatile, anything can happen, and mega-corporations swimming in greenbacks do not answer to anybody.

Activision can go on screwing over Infinity Ward and yet people will still buy their Call of Duty games. Valve can release Left 4 Dead 3 next year with no more care for Left 4 Dead 2, and I'd still want to get it. Heck, as much as I love Valve, where's Episode 3? Do they owe it to the masses though? Hell no. But journalists will be there writing about the wrongdoings of companies, absent games or failed promises (looking at you, Molyneux) so that the public will be reminded what they should be getting, not what they have been given.


Of course, I'm not saying that no one should hold journalists accountable. Most recent scandal I can think of is games writer Quintin Smith's review of MMO Age of Conan's Godslayer expansion being pulled off Eurogamer; it was considered an inadequate review as he only played beta rather than the full game. But really, I'd say it had something to do with Smith's negative review (read: corporate power over online media). Look at Kotaku Japan's snipe at Famitsu for the latter's excessive high praise given to PSP title Metal Gear Solid: Peacewalker. Also look at the firing of ex-Gamespot editor Jeff Gerstmann because he didn't score game reviews high enough.

Rupert Murdoch may be the evil villain of mainstream media but every games corporation could be a Murdoch in their own right; they certainly have most games media outlets in the palm of their hands. Especially with the economic crisis, most media outlets either have to crash and burn or unfortunately, stop biting the hand that feeds the most, and that's the games corporations. After all, it's the corporations that let journalists play their games earlier to write reviews and more importantly, buy out advertising space. Us folks at the bottom of the ladder don't do nothing but consume. We read journalists' words on games, but we're not the ones paying them.

This is sad because I've come across too many cases where the words of professional reviewers don't align with personal experiences I've had of some games. Take Alan Wake for example. This game got some crazy good acclaim from most major media outlets but when I played it, I thought it was a piece of shite scraped off the sole of better horror titles like Silent Hill, Dead Space, and Resident Evil. Sure, you can argue about opinions being "each to their own" but with some games, it's clear.


Let me think about this personally. Why do I write reviews? I'm not being paid for my opinion. And yet I do it because I love video games. I love playing something worthwhile, something that'll blow my mind. I'm sure that's the case for a lot of people, but journalists love what they do because they have license to translate their love into something others can read about. Someone needs to do it because it'll keep the masses informed. It will also keep games companies in check, making sure they keep doing what they do best better not worse. Journalists can also make sure our money goes into the right hands like indie devs and small companies that constantly push what gaming can do for us.

At the end of the day, I don't think I've got any major point to make other than that there are people out there making sense of video games on your behalf. It's no walk in the park, a lot of them have to do it for a lot less money, and at times, they'll get flak for it too. But by gawd, it's exciting. And thanks to these journalists, there's a large information flow that connects everybody to opinions, ideas, and the collective, undeniable love for video games.



Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Thinky stuff: Words are best!


Games aren't always about moving pictures and coordinated fingers. It's sometimes about words! WORDS I TELL YE! If it isn't, then Uncle Rocko is my dog.

Lots of interesting WORDS about games below, none written by me cause I've written loads of words on games already. So this is me taking a break, let other people do the talking. Worth reading all the same.

---

First, some war-related stuff. First blog looks at games in history, particularly board games in Nazi Germany and what that has to say about the time period. This extract gets heavy with games though...

None of this is to say videogames in particular are, or should be, overtly political. Games do not have to be "about" something. Yes, you can enjoy a game without discussing race, class, gender or religion. But that too is insignificant. Games will be "about" race, class, gender, and religion anyway. It's only natural... To completely avoid the medium's history, its potential, and the fact we imbue objects with meaning both intentionally and unintentionally, is self-administered ignorance.

Second blog post is an opinion piece on EA's upcoming Medal of Honor reboot. We all know modern warfare is the new fad thanks to the now-defunct Infinity Ward, but this guy believes it's bad. World War 2 is done and dusted so it's alright to make video games about that, but the war in the Middle East is far from over, so he thinks the new MoH is seriously an insensitive PR fail.

EA claim they “aren’t getting involved in politics”, but given that Goodrich proudly made boasts about their deep involvement with the US military (and even admits to cutting certain aspects of the game based on their say-so) that contention seems faintly ridiculous. Whether EA know it or not, this is a political exercise, with the possible aim of rehabilitating the US military (Goodrich repeatedly focused on the game’s attempts to accurately portray the ‘honour’ of the troops.) And when asked why EA chose this most contentious of locales for setting the game, Goodrich replied that the decision was taken simply because that was where the ‘bad guys are’.

Indeed, that particular comment had echoes of the good versus evil discourse so dominant in George W Bush’s America seems to be in full force here, the binary worldview that may have worked when fighting the Nazis but fails to convince this time around.

Final blog post is an interview with the guy who made the famed freaky, wack Sim City city (see it here). He spent four years pouring over equations and graph paper whilst playing the game in order to build the most epic and game-breaking city ever. Too-serious gaming much? And I thought formulating Modern Warfare 2 tactics in my head were epic.

Best bit of the interview...

Technically, no one is leaving or coming into the [game] city. Population growth is stagnant. Sims don’t need to travel long distances, because their workplace is just within walking distance. In fact they do not even need to leave their own block. Wherever they go it’s like going to the same place.

There are a lot of other problems in the city hidden under the illusion of order and greatness: Suffocating air pollution, high unemployment, no fire stations, schools, or hospitals, a regimented lifestyle - this is the price that these sims pay for living in the city with the highest population. It’s a sick and twisted goal to strive towards. The ironic thing about it is the sims in Magnasanti tolerate it. They don’t rebel, or cause revolutions and social chaos. No one considers challenging the system by physical means since a hyper-efficient police state keeps them in line. They have all been successfully dumbed down, sickened with poor health, enslaved and mind-controlled just enough to keep this system going for thousands of years. 50,000 years to be exact. They are all imprisoned in space and time.

That's all with the heavy stuff for now, folks! To reward you, here's a video of a fat cat standing up LOLOLOL.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Thinky stuff: Cool guys walk away from explosions + 100th post


This post has nothing to do with games, but in line with my recent review of Just Cause 2, I reckon this music video totally sums up the coolness of the game.

Oh and, I hit my 100th post just a bit ago.

Yay.

---



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sqz5dbs5zmo&feature=player_embedded

Friday, April 9, 2010

Thinky stuff: Life on Mars - The Video Game


Life on Mars is an awesome TV show. Just finished it a couple of nights ago. I reckon it should be made into a video game. Hear me out.

---

For those who don't know, Life on Mars is a 2006 British crime/detective series about a policeman Sam Tyler who gets into a car accident that sends him back in time to 1973. Then, lost in a time he doesn't know, where the police force is ruthless and corrupt, he has to find out why he is there and how to get back.

I reckon that using Bioware's Mass Effect 2 engine, an awesome game could be made of the series.

It'll be a mystery-detective game, so you have to walk about crime scenes analyzing stuff, and talking to people. In fact, the talking to people bits are the most important part of the show and the game. Hence, Mass Effect 2's nice conversation wheel can come into play along with the nice cinematics.

There have to be a lot of hard choices to make, right things to say at the right time, be it when questioning suspects, or getting morsels of information out of wary witnesses. Then, like in Mass Effect 2, there'll be a Paragon/Evil mouse icon flashing at the moments when you can pull the Good Cop/Bad Cop move. Maybe you'll throw the guy up against the wall and punch his gut if he's not being helpful, or you can stop DCI Gene Hunt from doing something corrupt, like planting evidence on a bad guy.


In Life on Mars, Sam Tyler always appears in opposition to the police force because his methods of policing are ethical, logical and scientific. So in an interesting twist, every time you do a Good Cop move, the other characters will get really pissed. Gene Hunt especially; not only will some of his conversation options be disabled, he will antagonize you for always going against him.

Life on Mars doesn't have many shoot-outs, but I guess in the interest of making this a mass marketable game, there's got to be some action bits for those short-attention spanned fools. Lots of running after bad guys.

Squad-based gameplay? Sure. You've got Detective Annie Cartwright and Chris Skelton backing you up, and instead of just plain ordering them around to help you shoot stuff, you could assign them tasks such as looking for the murder weapon in a landfill, or interrogating a group of witnesses, so you can get the information faster.

The actual detective gameplay will be to collect enough evidence, or concrete confessions from witnesses, suspects, etc. to put a criminal away behind bars. There'll be no hand-holding in the game, the player has to make connections for themselves. Like if a witness mentions a brother to the killer, the player has to decide to go find this brother, or not. People will lie and lead you down the wrong path. Who can you trust? In the case at hand, and with the wider conspiracy within the police force.

Relationships? Totally. Life on Mars is all about the relationships in the police force, gaining or losing respect from the people by the choices you make. Like when Sam lets Ryan walk towards a bomb about to explode unknowingly, causing the latter's hospitalization. This leads to everyone else on the force being pissed at Sam, ostracizing him. People won't listen to your orders, and as before, conversation choices close off. Relationships are big in this game, and love interests? Sure, you've got just Annie to focus on but she's one tough cookie to crack.


Madness. Sam Tyler is constantly referring to his life in 2006, which is both comedic in some instances and dramatic in others. Like how in one scene, Sam tells Annie he'll reward her with a Kit-Kat for her good work. And she's like "Kit-Kat?" and Sam says, "Yeah, a chunky one." Annie walks away offended. Why? No chunky Kit-Kats back then LOL.

Anyway, Sam in the game will have visions/hallucinations, hear voices in the oddest of places, and you have to juggle police work in 1973 whilst uncovering the mystery behind your time traveling. But the more you chase your madness, the more distance you put between yourself and Annie. An interesting dilemma for the players.

The graphics will be superb. The Bioware team will do their research so well that they'll get the 1970s Manchester vibe down. The industrial feel, the red bricked houses and most importantly, the depressing gray weather.

The music is going to kick ass, just like the TV show, with most tracks from the 60s and 70s. Including David Bowie's Life on Mars, Elton John's Rocket Man, Neil Young, etc.

Voice-acting will be top notch. We'll get all the actors and actresses of the series including John Simm and definitely Philip Glenister. Besides, all of 'em save Liz White and John Simm are still playing their characters for the spin-off show Ashes to Ashes.

Most important thing? Your choices will have an impact on the story. Just like in the first episode, when Sam Tyler chooses to let a suspect walk because of a lack of evidence. And in doing so, the bank robber robbed again and in the process shoots an innocent bystander. The blood is on Sam's hands, your hands. That's compelling gaming right there.

Finally, then Bioware can say "Suck it, Heavy Rain!"


Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Thinky stuff: Why so lonely shooter?


For a long time in shooters, we've traversed all sorts of dangerous locales and done everything from saving our Navajo girlfriends, get out/into Hell, and stop evil Nazi forces from world domination.

But why do we always have to do it alone?!?

---

In all fairness, I'm not saying it's a bad thing all the time, and certainly in some stories/situations, it's necessary to have the protagonist be alone for things to play out as the game devs want them to.

But when certain games force this "you have to go it alone" feel, damn, it really gets on my nerves. Recent game in question, Aliens versus Predator. I've been getting some time in to single-player, and the Marines campaign in particular - why is it that in the first five seconds of the game, my badass squad of hardcore Marines ready to kick some Alien butt gets decimated save for me - especially when my name is Rookie. Hardly the long-time surviving veteran eh? They might as well have para-dropped me into enemy territory alone in the first place. Why bother with all the extra animations?

Then for the rest of the game I'm forced to traverse dark, Alien-infested corridors alone with some woman communicating/annoying via walkie-talkie, refusing to come out of her hidey-hole to help me in person.

Blasted Bioshock 2 has you running around alone for pretty much the entirety of the game (Little Sisters on your shoulder don't count), save one teasing moment when Sinclair and you are just separated by glass, before he scampers off to hide in a train.


In Crysis why can't I kick butt with my squad of supermen? Why is it that I'm so damn lucky to be the only one not eaten by aliens? And I reckon we'd get the job done much faster if a whole group of super-suited soldiers (alliteration!) cloaked into an enemy base together and leveled it without having to worry about being outnumbered.

In Wolfenstein, I get all excited when I'm thrown in with some French resistance fighters ready to kick some Nazi ass, only to have my heart broken a minute later when they get wiped out as easy as running a knife through hot butter, by some Nazi with a big gun. And I'm the only one who doesn't die ... again. Was I was born different or something? I have a 100 hit points, but all the other good guys only seem to have 1.

Basically, me no likey when I'm separated from my squad/the sole survivor/ordered to do something dangerous alone/dumb enough to be doing something different in a different place from my friends altogether.

Or your spunky hot chick friend/cool badass buddy goes, "I'm going to check in here for a second. You go on ahead." *Slaps forehead at foreboding recipe for disaster*

Which is why games like the Half-Life 2 Episodes are so refreshing. Alyx is by your side pretty much the entire time, kicking butt and covering yours. We need more shooters doing that. It also seems a hell of a lot more realistic than just one guy saving the world.

Rant over.

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Thinky stuff: Haz moarz Mass Effectz 2


As you may have been able to tell from my extremely lengthy review of Mass Effect 2, I like the game very much. And if you couldn't tell, or didn't read it (shame on you), well then now you know.

I read a lot of other gaming blogs and sites across the Internet Universe, and it appears I'm not the only one who went gaga for this epic sci-fi space opera saga-of-the-century bonanza. And I don't normally want to use my blog as a dumping ground for other people's write-ups, but there have been some entertaining readz aboot the game in question.

So if you're interested in reading more words on the topic, click on below. A little warning, some spoilers abound. But by now, you should've already played the game!!!

---

First up, two reviews of Mass Effect 2 from the folks down at Rock, Paper, Shotgun. I like dem dudes at RPS, they be smart about dem video games, so that's pretty much all the testimonials I need to give. Read here, and here.

This 'un is a little biased because it's a Comparison-o-article between PS3 juggernaut Uncharted 2 (which I thought was also pretty awesome) and Mass Effect 2. I think the reasoning behind doing this article has to do with how Uncharted 2 was heralded as a godsent when it first came out, and perhaps some critics have grown tired of hearing that. Anyway, good reading all the same, click here. There's also a little console-war brewing in between the lines, but if you're a PC gamer like me, ignore 'em.

Two more and that'll be all I'll talk about this game (maybe not). Both from Gamer Melodico, a new blog to have popped into the stratosphere some weeks back, and it's proving to be rather good. I like this guy's post about Shephard's anti-press tendencies across both the first game and sequel. Hilarious stuff.

The second post is about a romantic tryst the writer had in the game. Not only did he believe the romance was pretty good but it also spoke volumes about the personalized nature of ME2 for every individual player.

And that's all folks!

Monday, January 4, 2010

Thinky stuff: Happy New Year 2010

So Happy New Year all my lovely readers. I hope you all had a long and enjoyable weekend. I certainly did.

So I don't usually do personal posts, especially when I promised myself this blog would focus specifically on the video games I've played and thought about, but meh, it's this new year and I've got stuff to say that is games-related and also in some ways personal-related.

---

First of all, Ubisoft is in Singapore. This may be new news to some, old news to others, but whatever it is, I WANT IN.

And to learn that much of Assassin's Creed 2 was developed here shows that Singapore is pretty big in the world of games development. Not to mention, Crytek chose Singapore for its destination for a conference of games not so long ago. And don't forget, World Cyber Games is held here every so often. At least the country is gaining a larger and better rep than dem folk down unda' who instead of progressing video games, regress with their whole censorship dumbness.


So anyway, with a major games studio in such close proximity to me, my dream of working in the games industry is becoming ever increasingly apparent. But I'm going to need some technical experience - just having academic or theoretical knowledge to back up passion isn't enough. Anyone can study games, but not everyone can understand how to build them properly. So that is what I shall be learning in my last 6 months before graduating. Game design, here I come.

---


I know I blog only about PC games, but I REALLY want a PS3. I'm a big fan of Final Fantasy, and everything about it, but the problem is, after Final Fantasy 9, I haven't had an opportunity to play any FF titles. I didn't own a PS2 either. With the recent release of Final Fantasy XIII, there is no way in hell I'm going to miss out on it. It just looks so magnificent. Alas, PS3's are so damn expensive.

Square Enix really should port FF games for the PC!!!!

Plus, now all game devs are releasing first for consoles then only PCs. why!?! WHY?!?! (Okay, I know why, I'm just crying out in anguish). Plus, Uncharted 2 is a PS3-only title. Sad-face.

---

I've played much Modern Warfare 2 and it doesn't look like my interest in it is going to wane anytime soon. And I can lose interest in a game REALLY quickly. But that just goes to show how damn awesome MW2's multiplayer is.

---

Games I am hotly anticipating in the coming months?

Mass Effect 2 on Jan 29th. The first sucked, here's to hoping the second doesn't.

Bioshock 2 on Feb 2nd. The first was awesome, but can 2k Games sustain interest by returning us to same ol' Rapture a second time round?

AvP reboot on Feb 19th. Three-way multiplayer deathmatch just sounds too epic.


Splinter Cell: Conviction on Feb 26th. The Luc Besson movie Taken channeled into video game. What more could you ask for?

And Assassin's Creed 2, Mafia 2, and Just Cause 2 sometime soon!!!! All those 2s!!!!

---


Also been playing a bit of Canabalt. Seriously, this game is thoroughly wacked. In my opinion, it's like Mirror's Edge distilled to its finest parts - the escape. Super furious fast paced action with just a single button. It induces the "just-one-more-try" tic in your brain.

Anyway, that's it for now with my PERSONAL post. Will return to talking about games and only games next post onwards.

Until then, be happy and play lots of games (:

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Thinky stuff: Far Cry 2 in retrospect


I write this post in response to Trent Polack's ode to Far Cry 2 as his game of the decade, and Ben Abraham's epic game diary of his time in the game. These two well-respected game bloggers, amongst many others consider Far Cry 2 an amazing game of legendary proportions (yes, I'm pumping the superlatives) because of everything it represents in terms of sandbox and dynamically spontaneous action, based upon individual player choices.

But in my opinion, despite Far Cry 2 being a good game, I wouldn't go so far as calling it spectacular. And after hearing so much praise heaped on the game even to this day, I had to return to it myself and see what the fuss is all about. What I found was that all the original issues I had with the game still stand today.

But if Ubisoft tweaked a few things, the game would be the stellar title it should've been.

---

Immersion

I've heard this one at least a dozen times; the way you can almost "feel" the sweltering heat as you scream across the African desert in a 4x4, or how the towns are positively buzzing with tension and alive with people.

What people? What atmosphere? What heat? Sure the graphics can make it feel like you're really in some savanna, or a lush jungle, but as far as civilization is concerned, Far Cry 2 is too lacking in populace. The only time you ever see non-hostile NPCs is at the very beginning, as you are driven towards the town. You see women and children and random dudes but they seem to be going in the opposite direction to you. The driver informs you everyone is trying to leave the country. This means all the villages are either devoid of life or filled with angry people with guns.


So to make Far Cry 2 more immersive, instead of having all the people disappear, they should've made the towns more vibrant with communities that don't try to shoot you on sight: have people going about their daily business, from selling and buying things at a market, kids playing in the dusty streets, women going about their housekeeping chores, etc.

The player is already in constant danger traveling between places, with jeeps chasing your ass, and outposts that spray bullets at your car every time you pass. Having non-hostile communities not only gives the player an opportunity for respite, it also contrasts the violence with the peaceful, cultural aspects the country has to offer.

Even if your interaction with non-hostile NPCs is minimal, i.e. have them there for show even if you can't talk to them shows that you are not alone in this big, bad world full of big, bad people.


Companionship

In Far Cry 2, you pick up buddies at an expat bar (which, as discussed above, is too empty to be fun) and have them help you out in two ways - they give an alternative plan of action for missions, or help rescue you if you go down in a fight. Outside of this, they have nothing interesting about them, and reveal only piecemeals of personal histories.

Such static programming may mean the player quickly understands the function of the buddies in the game, but I'd like to have seen something more dynamic. Didn't Half-Life 2: Episode 2 come out exactly one year before Far Cry 2?

Why mention that awesome game from Valve? you ask.


Simple. HL2: Episode 2 had an interesting gimmick in that Alyx, one of the main characters to the Half-Life story and your best buddy, follows you around for most of the game; dispatching enemies and sitting in the car beside you. It made the world less lonely as she talked to you, and reacted to the world along with you. Far Cry 2 needed to do that.

For much of the latter game, you are driving across very pretty landscapes, but it's all so very lonely. Having someone sit beside you - perhaps telling you about their lives before you arrived, or help fend off all those irritating jeeps chasing you, would make the game a lot more fun and the buddies all that more meaningful in your game existence.

Plus, when the shocking twist comes at the end, I think it would be a whole lot more profound.

Characters

All this talk about more affecting companions leads me to my next big point. Characters in Far Cry 2 are poorly written. Perhaps Ubisoft's concern is that in order to focus on the main point of the game, which is to shoot stuff, and do it fast, they need to cut back on lengthy talky bits and deep characterization.

But heck, go all out to make the best immersive game you can, I say. Which means all the bosses, and their assistants that you get your missions from should be made more well-rounded. Right now, they could very well be replaced by cardboard cut-outs with robotic voices, and we could care less.


Bring out more of their paranoia at the other faction, some underlying emotions, anxieties, motives for acting the way they do. Give us more and more of the characters. Now, they just speak too fast and not at all about anything other than "go-here-do-that". Even the buddies could do with a little more depth, although I have to praise the visual design of all the characters, they are each individually quite interesting.

The Jackal I must add though, is a well written character. Of course, he is the most prominent character for the plot, and the catalyst for everything that happens around you in the game world.

Story

I played Uncharted 2 recently, and the story is just so compelling and a rollicking good time as an adventure. That's what Far Cry 2 should've done. Made an adventure story set in Africa. It may be a little cliched, but at least it is at once familiar to audiences but also fresh, in terms of it not being done to death yet in the gaming world.

This is definitely a very strong personal opinion but I believe we should be given better reasons to blowing things up, or assassinating this person or raiding that outpost. Give me a strong enough motive to want to fight these people badly.


In the game, we are just blunt tools acting on the whims of these faction lords, fighting their pointless proxy wars so that we can earn diamonds to buy the next big gun. I don't really care if I've racked up a body count, or leveled an entire village. But my point is, I should care. I even sometimes forget the main reason why I'm in Africa which is to find and kill the Jackal.

I have no doubt that the writers at Ubisoft are good enough to maintain the game's high degree of freedom and choice whilst having a focused story. Granted, Far Cry 2's ultimate design is in that it is not shackled by a story so that players can create their own as they play, but after awhile, even sandbox without meaning or focus can grow tiresome.

And if the writers at Ubisoft want ideas for what kind of story to make, I have a possible plot opening:

*COPYRIGHTED* You come to Africa to find and kill the Jackal, but after being struck down by malaria, you are saved and nursed back to health by a small village community. You come to live with and befriend these simple people, until the factions come through and ravage the peaceful village.

Therein lies your motive to fight: to save the lives of your friends, or even take revenge on those war-mongering fools. Or not at all, and go work for the factions instead. Boom! Cue epic music. *COPYRIGHT END*


---

When I played the game last year, I was seriously head over heels for it. It did the sandbox thing really, really well and I preferred it to that other awesome open, lush-world shooter, Crysis. The range of weaponry, the realism in recoil, firepower, and wear, driving across pretty landscapes, lots of dynamic player-driven violence and action, etc.

But at the end of the day, my concerns are primarily based on immersion, and I seriously believe if Ubisoft considers these, Far Cry 3 will be a kick-ass game.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Thinky stuff: Junch's Top 10 games of 2009

Finally, folks. We have come to a decade. It only seemed like yesterday when the world was in a frenzy over the whole millennium hoo-ha, and I watched as a man zoomed around a stadium with a jetpack.

But that's not what I'm here to talk about. I'm here to talk about my games for 2009. This year has been quite a dry one to be honest, there have been some stellar titles, but nothing spectacular or earth-shaking. With the economic turmoil in the world at large, even the game devs are either cutting back, delaying, or just plain canceling games altogether. Rest in peace, Duke Nukem...

Here we go...

---

10. The Sims 3


The most highly anticipated release from EA and Will Wright since his failure with Spore (in my opinion). A game that got the women ga-ga again to play house, and made everything seem all that more realistic with improved A.I. and sweet graphics. I watched as a bunch of friends go through entire days without feeding themselves (no joke) just because they were more interested in feeding their Sims and making them go about their daily business - that was how great the game was. It also saw the return of sadism with the creepy players walling up their Sims and watching them pee themselves to death. Gross.

It also spawned some beautiful gaming diaries, such as Alice & Kev which chronicled the lives of two Sims, showcasing how powerful EA's new A.I engine was, with the capacity for depth of emotion, and that you could pretty much leave Sims to live their own lives with little interference from the omniscient player.

9. Secret of Monkey Island (Special Edition)


I'll be honest. I'm not a big fan of the adventure genre. I don't seem to have the patience for finding hidden objects that make other hidden objects work. Or understanding an obscure reference that would lead to unlocking another obscure puzzle. Give me a rocket launcher and I'll clear a path through whatever obstacle's in my way. That's also probably a very obnoxious thing to say.

But LucasArts did something special with their Special Edition-ed Secret of Monkey Island. They made their greatest adventure game all shiny and updated for us new generation of gamers, too young back then to appreciate or even play it. The jokes are all there, the fun is all there, now even with Threepwood's awesome voice and a hint system!

The hint system works superbly well, slowly easing you towards the answer if you need it. For an impatient rage-quitter like me to have played through the entire game is saying something. A must-try and a look back at a bygone era where adventure games were the staple of the video games market because it was all that the technology was capable of.

A game brilliantly crafted and written. LucasArts should consider making new IP with their talent for such games. It would totally sell well. And hopefully, they'll also be encouraged to re-release all their old Monkey Island titles in the same style as the Secret of Monkey Island.

8. Street Fighter 4


As I mentioned in the review for this game, the PC has not been graced with many bash 'em-up titles. Probably because we don't have couches, and widescreen TVs, and analog stick things to control women with large, gravity-defying boobs and men that look like they've swallowed several barrels when they were babies. But Capcom was kind enough to get SF4 on the PC, a game which heralded the return to the no-nonsense side-scrolling, kick, punch, ultra awesomeness.

The cel-shading graphics is just brilliant for the new generation, the characters are sumptuously updated with very unique, flashy moves. But the most important thing is that the game is highly accessible, from those who are prone to button-mashing to the most hardcore SF aficionados who can perfect-combo your ass to oblivion. Plus, as a PC gamer, I'll have to say controlling the characters with keyboard is way easier than using a stoopid analog stick thingy.

It was a horrible missed opportunity with their poorly drawn and scripted anime cutscenes, cutscenes which they could've used to build an epic storyline with some awesome action. But I have a good feeling people just skipped over them to get to the gameplay. The game itself had a tonne of attitude, and immense replayability, so it wins.

7. Braid


A game and a piece of profound art, Braid does the unthinkable. It has the simplicity of Super Mario but the complexity of an academic text on philosophy. To use time as a mechanic is sheer genius, and it does so in a way more kick-ass than even that Prince of Persia game that everyone likes so much.

It's the first game to make you feel true anguish and pain, not just from the perfect conundrums of puzzles that Jonathan Blow devises for you at each level, but because of the story that the game takes place in. And of course, the final twist.

The unbelievably sickeningly epic legendary final twist that has you clutching your head and screaming at your computer screen when it comes around. You cannot say you have experienced emotion in games if you have not played Braid. Many casual and even recreational gamers will be put off by the sheer difficulty of the game, but to gamers who consider themselves connoisseurs of games as an art-form, they must play Braid.

That is all.

6. Borderlands


This was a hard one to consider for my Top 10, but then I recalled all the great memories I had with this, on just one night play-through with a couple of friends. We started the game up, shot through countless enemies, squealed like little girls at the great loot we'd pick up, and cut across the bleak landscape in two-man buggies. As cowboys in the Wild West, we ran screaming from humongous monsters, and shouted strategies for taking down some bad-ass bosses.

I honestly believe Borderlands got down the adventure aspect of cooperative gaming to near-perfection, better even perhaps than that 4-person zombie shooter we all know and love. It was very Diablo-esque in its role-playing elements making the game even more compulsively addictive. And all that gun porn like the 6-shot rocket launcher. Now that's just obscene.

5. Left 4 Dead 2


Before Left 4 Dead 1 came out, I must've followed all the news of the game's development like a stalker to J-Lo (if people still bothered stalking her in this day and age). When it came out, it was fun and crazy and everything I'd wanted and more in a cooperative zombie shooting experience. Then just six months later, Left 4 Dead 2 was announced and I was extremely skeptical.

But Valve have proven themselves time after time, and honestly, no IP of Valve's has blown up dismally. In fact, they've all been critical successes, and when the world dissented that Left 4 Dead 2 was coming out way too soon, all the devs said was "Trust us."

Now I know why they had to make it an entirely separate game. The content is twice that of the first game, more guns and melee weapons means more fun ways to kill zombies. The settings are alive in the sequel, very lovingly crafted along with stand-out characters. The game that Left 4 Dead 1 was supposed to be and better. The action is even more high-octane, the zombies more ferocious, and the characters more real.

Whilst cooperative of the first one with friends seemed to fizz out after a couple of months, I can see this one being played very far into the future. It's also a harder game, with a realism mode for the psychotic. And that one finale with the fireworks on the concert stage is just epic.

4. Batman: Arkham Asylum


I had no idea what to expect when I first got this game. Batman doesn't have flight or laser eyes or super strength like Superman, nor can he scale buildings as easily as Spidey. So what kind of game will it be then?!

A stealth-action title is what. Tapping into all that is great about Batman as a superhero, the player has to use their ingenuity and stealth skills to overcome most challenges. And his tech gadgets. And the hand-to-hand combat. My god, what awesome hand-to-hand combat. The awesome camera angles as you broke the bones and smashed in the faces of thugs. For those of you who've seen the Chinese kungfu movie Ip Man, you'll know what I'm talking about. For those that haven't, watch it.

The story for the game is well-written, the lore is so richly realized with the Unreal 3 engine, and the voice-acting is top-notch. Even though it's a computer generated character, the Joker in Arkham Asylum may even beat Heath Ledger's performance of the bad ass villain. The game's version is positively dripping with psychotic evil. And Batman is just so tank.

But what I liked most is that the gameplay's mechanics are so pitch perfect that players understand what needs to be done at every turn, and the controls are so simple but have much depth to them when used properly. A highly focused title that was fun every second, well-written, and wrapped in the shiny package of the Unreal 3 engine. Roll on Batman 2.



The shooter of the year obviously. Extremely exciting and not for the faint-hearted. It's like those new Transformer flicks, high on spectacle, low on brains. But it did have a more focused storyline than the first Modern Warfare, and even World at War.

The shooting elements are all intact and awesome, and the graphics are the best in years, but the thing that carries this game far is the multiplayer element. Now there are more ways to make a player obsessed with the game, from persistent rankings as well as drip-fed continual rewards like weapon and cosmetic upgrades. The new matchmaking service works well, and for people with poor internet connections, there is less worry about lag and no need to look for dedicated servers with smooth connections. It's just as simple as hopping in and letting the system find the game that best suits you.

Ruthless and highly competitive multiplayer makes this LEGENDARY.

2. Dragon Age: Origins


Finally, the return of the glorious Bioware. I personally thought Mass Effect was a load of horribleness, and we can forget Jade Empire. But everyone has good memories of Knights of the Old Republic. And Dragon Age brings back all that is awesome about Bioware's epic RPG adventures - deep and strategic combat/gameplay, expansive universes rich with lore, well-written characters and plot, and most importantly with Dragon Age, grey moral choices with significant consequences.

After so long, finally a game that doesn't show you simple black and white, like Fallout 3, or even Fable. The first game I've played where you are unsure whether any of the choices you make are the best ones. That you couldn't please everyone and be the white knight in shining armor at the same time. A game that drew me in as well as any Final Fantasy title with compelling characters and an exciting journey that you wish would never end. So immersive and thoroughly addictive. It's like reading one of those high-fantasy novels (I don't personally read them though) like Dragonlance and Dungeons & Dragons. I'm already looking forward to expansions to prolong the story.



In one word: Breathtaking.

Now to talk about it in many words. Surprised y'all didn't I? Not many people would consider this their number one game, and most people would've forgotten that the PC port version came out with little fanfare early this year.

But I was mesmerized. A game where the world was so sleek and shiny and beautifully minimalist, the colors so strong and not one line out of place. And the gameplay stood out for being so different, innovative, and exciting. You spent more time dodging bullets than shooting your opponents. Mirror's Edge was a game that literally played through all the escape scenes of every action movie ever made.

When I was a kid, I was so enthralled by those people on YouTube doing parkour, with their fancy somersaults, back-flips, and crazy jumps across large gaps. I'm even tried to do a little parkour of my own, and failed miserably. But with Mirror's Edge, I get to play out my fantasy. The rooftops are my playground, and it is so much more cool when you are directly involved in the leaping over of skyscrapers and clambering up buildings rather than it being a simple push of a single button, ala Assassin's Creed (and the spacebar). Letting the players control all the movements made the game challenging and highly rewarding. And they got the fluidity of motion just right.

The story was different also, and made me want more when it had ended. It didn't have large explosions, it didn't try to dazzle you with super shiny graphics (all though it was pretty shiny), and the story wasn't bogged down in absurdities. It was just you and the world. An environment constructed with one purpose, for free running.

Mirror's Edge was the first game that truly made you feel like you were in the skin of your avatar, of Faith. The way your head bobs, hearing the heavy breathing in your ears, seeing your hands and legs shoot out in front of you as you try to reach that ledge that just seems a little too far...

And the soundtrack is so modern and awesome. Listen to "Still Alive" on YouTube for Mirror's Edge OST, not to be confused with the one for Portal.

---

And there you have it folks, my top 10 games of 2009. Other titles, although not in my top 10 that are worth mentioning include:

1. The Tales of Monkey Island series

2. Torchlight

3. Tropico 3

It was a fun year, some interesting titles, but also some horrible failures like Saboteur and Prototype. But I'm certainly looking forward to 2010, a year when all the great titles we've been waiting for are finally released: Bioshock 2, Assassin's Creed 2, Mafia 2, Starcraft 2, Alan Wake. All the 2s LOL.



Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Thinky stuff: A thinky blog about thinky things in games

Whilst I try to formulate the words to what I think about Modern Warfare 2, Dragon Age, and Left 4 Dead 2, here's something for you people to chew on.

Quite an interesting site if you ask me: gausswerks


A game design guy, Jack Monahan, takes games that are either already released or have become vaporware and talks about potential ways he could make them better. And boy, is he making them better. Amidst all the interesting texty text about concepts and visual design, and game-play, etc. he peppers it with concept arts of his own for the games, and he's got some ideas that I think even the game devs should take into consideration.

Particular noteworthy posts includes one where he talks architecture and space in a level, and its implications in Left 4 Dead and the other is a "What If?" post about one of the earliest designs of Half-Life starring Ivan the Biker, and "what if" that got release instead of what we all know today as the greatest game on earth (notice my references to Valve games, that's because I heart Valve like it's the schiz).

Anyhoo, the site can be found upon clickity clack of said link.

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Thinky stuff: The kill-joy for all video gamers in Australia - The Classification Review Board and a Politician

Below is an opinion piece I wrote for a university assignment, in the vein of something to be published in a newspaper. I decided to post it here because it's games-related and of course, my thoughts on Australia's games classification system - a relevant issue for you guys to understand. It's lengthy, hope you like it.

***

Early in October, gamers rejoiced when the ban was lifted on the soon-to-be-released sequel to Australia’s favorite zombie video game, Left 4 Dead 2. Prior to this, Left 4 Dead 2 was refused classification because the three-person outfit running Australia’s entire Review Board were perturbed by all the virtual blood, guts, and gore on display. Valve, the game’s developers resubmitted a version of the game that had all the violence taken out so even 15 year olds could play.

Good for 15 year olds. But what about the 18 year olds? Or 30 year olds? What about the people who are mature and old enough to know that violence in reality is never a good thing, but could be fantasized in the realms of entertainment as a cathartic outlet for our pent-up animalistic rage?

Whilst it is admirable that these three valiant defendants of all that is pure and innocent in the world look out for the little ones who may supposedly turn to guns and drugs because of video games, they are in turn preventing the possibility for games to mature as an expressive artistic medium, and is costing developers and consumers alike. Furthermore, the Review Board appears illogical in the public’s eyes when just a year earlier, they allowed the release of the first Left 4 Dead with little fanfare, and no censorship. That game was far more violent than the censored version of Left 4 Dead 2.

The recommendation this writer suggests, something the public has demanded for so long, is the introduction of an R18+ classification on top of the current MA15+. In doing so, the children can be protected and the adults can have their thought-provoking, uncensored life-in-art video games fun.

But the final boss to be defeated, standing between all Australian video gamers and their ultimate prize of gaming freedom is the South-Australian Attorney General Michael Atkinson.

He is the sole obstacle, the last of Australia’s attorneys-general deliberately holding out against a necessary unanimous decision to implement a new classification system that includes the R18+ rating.

His argument for opposing the R18+ rating is one that has been heard before all over the world by paranoids such as the infamous and now-disbarred attorney Jack Thompson. Atkinson argues violent games “increase the risk of children and vulnerable adults being exposed to damaging images and messages” and that as video games are “interactive… they have a much greater influence than viewing a movie does.”

Sounds familiar? That’s because every conservative government/regime/tyrant makes video games scapegoats to the violence in their countries/state/district. The Columbine shooters were avid fans of violent computer games, and just recently, a drunken father in Texas allegedly got into a spat with his son over a missing video game and shot him.

The argument to prove the video game dissenters wrong is that countless scientists, psychologists, and sociologists around the world have worked to prove whether video games provokes violence, and all results conclude that there is no empirical evidence to suggest it does. In fact, evidence has shown that there were deeper issues at stake in each of these horror stories; for instance, lest we forget, the Texan father was drunk at the time he killed his son, had prior criminal history, and has been abusive before. The Columbine shooters were under the influence of drugs that brought about their psychotic tendencies. Also, maybe, just maybe, the availability of guns to anybody in America might have something to do with all this death. To simply say that games are the root problem would be shallow and illogical.

But returning to the main argument, the absence of an R18+ rating would not be desirable, even to Atkinson, because logically, such a classification would indeed shield young minds from all the violent, sex-crazed, drug-fuelled material. In this year alone, those 15 year olds we seek to protect have been playing games which involve shooting innocent civilians in the head or engaging in unsavory activities like drug-running – all quite legally. Because of the current rating system, teenagers could get their hands on mature titles like Grand Theft Auto 4 and Fallout 3, exactly the opposite of what Atkinson wants.

This is what can be predicted to happen by having an R18+ rating: for one, we won’t be the butt of jokes from other countries as to our backwardness; two, people have to show identification to verify age upon purchase of games thereby keeping the kids away from the adult stuff. And if Atkinson worries that in homes the games will end up in the hands of the children of gamers anyway, there is such a thing as a “parental lock” to deny them access. Finally, everyone will be happy to play video games the way they were made to be played.

One thing good has come out of this Left 4 Dead 2 debacle though; people are talking about the classification issue again. And hopefully Atkinson will see that imposing his personal view on an entire country, no matter how noble the intentions, is an abuse of his position. This writer waits with bated breath for the day when positive change comes, until then, there are zombies to kill. All this anger at the Classification Review Board needs to be let out somewhere.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...